I have stayed in many rental homes and you can often tell if the owner really cares by the knives. Are they decent quality and sharp. If so, you have an owner who cares about buying quality equipment AND maintaining it. We had two chefs staying in the house and we loved the knives (oh yea they have a rice maker which came in handy for both the sushi we cut and the steak burritos).
Everything else was great too—outside shower was awesome, interior design was great, bedrooms provided lots of privacy (ie quiet), great beach chairs with mats too (and cruiser bikes and golf clubs although we don’t golf), easy walk to Wylies beach, and great planting providing privacy from neighbors.
I won’t ever stay anywhere else on the island.